STUBBLE BURNING: FARM FIRE COUNT IS NOT ENOUGH

22 Nov 2026

Tags: Environment   Conservation   Pollution control

Source: The Indian Express

Context: Satellites have recorded 16,070 farm-fire incidents across northern India during the ongoing kharif harvesting season. However, actual stubble burning may be significantly higher because conventional satellite monitoring misses fires occurring outside observation windows, small fires and low-intensity burning. The article highlights the need to supplement active-fire counts with burnt-area mapping and ground-level monitoring.

Stubble Burning and Its Impact

  • Meaning: Stubble burning refers to the practice of setting fire to crop residues, particularly paddy straw, left behind after harvesting to clear fields quickly for the next crop.
  • Seasonal concentration: It is particularly prevalent in Punjab and Haryana during October–mid-November, when farmers have only 10–20 days between paddy harvesting and wheat sowing.
  • Air pollution: During peak burning periods, stubble burning can contribute more than 30% of Delhi's PM2.5 pollution, according to the Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology (IITM).
  • Environmental consequences: Releases particulate matter and greenhouse gases, deteriorates soil health and adversely affects human health.

How Farm Fires Are Monitored

  • Satellite-based monitoring: India primarily uses daily thermal-anomaly observations from polar-orbiting satellites such as Suomi-NPP, Aqua and Terra, operated by NASA and the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
  • Thermal anomaly: Refers to an unusual rise in surface temperature compared with the surrounding area's normal temperature, indicating a possible fire.
  • VIIRS sensor: The Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite aboard Suomi-NPP detects active fires using infrared observations.
  • MODIS sensor: The Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer aboard Aqua and Terra provides observations used for active-fire detection.
  • Limited observation windows: Satellites detect fires only during their scheduled overpasses, generally between 10:30 a.m. and 1:30 p.m. Consequently, fires occurring in the late afternoon and evening may remain undetected. Aqua's overpass has shifted from around 1:30 p.m. to approximately 4 p.m.
  • Use of fire-count data: Satellite observations are used to estimate emissions from crop-residue burning. IITM incorporates these estimates into air-quality assessments and forecasts for Delhi-NCR, influencing decisions such as the implementation of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP).

Limitations of Existing Satellite Monitoring

  • Shift in burning timings: A November 2025 study by ISRO's Space Applications Centre, Ahmedabad, documented a shift in peak farm-burning activity towards late afternoon and evening in Punjab and Haryana.
  • Inadequate detection: Conventional polar-orbiting satellites fail to capture the full extent of farm fires because of limited observation windows. A 2026 study using South Korean satellite data identified a sharp increase in farm fires around and after 4 p.m., a trend developing since 2022.
  • Earlier research findings: A 2019 study by Columbia University-affiliated researchers found that MODIS active-fire products missed more than 90% of fires in northwest India, partly because of their small size, short duration and occurrence between satellite overpasses.
  • Partial burning: Low-intensity or partial burning, particularly in Haryana, produces weaker thermal signals, making detection difficult.
  • Cloud cover: Clouds obstruct satellite observations and reduce the availability of reliable fire-detection data.
  • Mismatch between fire counts and pollution: Despite a decline in officially recorded satellite fire counts, aerosol pollution over the Indo-Gangetic Plain increased between 2022 and 2025, according to the cited research.

Why Fire Counts Alone Are Insufficient

  • Fire count vs actual damage: Active-fire monitoring records fires detected at the time of satellite observation but does not necessarily measure the total agricultural area affected.
  • Evidence from Haryana and Punjab: FOREST, a non-profit organisation, found the following differences between 2024 and 2025:
IndicatorHaryanaPunjab
Fire incidents (2024 → 2025)1,406 → 66210,909 → 5,114
Burnt area in 20247,117 sq km23,262 sq km
Burnt area in 20258,812 sq km19,757 sq km

Key observation: In Haryana, recorded fire incidents declined substantially, while estimated burnt area increased. In Punjab, the decline in burnt area was considerably smaller than the decline in recorded fire incidents. Thus, fewer detected fires do not necessarily indicate a proportionate reduction in stubble burning.

Burnt-Area Mapping: An Alternative Approach

  • Meaning: Burnt-area (BA) mapping identifies changes in the land surface after a fire rather than detecting only active fires at a particular moment.
  • Working mechanism: Researchers compare satellite images taken before and after suspected burning. Since fire changes the way the land surface reflects sunlight, these changes help identify burnt patches.
  • Advantages: Burnt-area signals may remain detectable for longer than active-fire signals, helping capture small, low-intensity and short-duration fires missed during satellite overpasses.
  • Sentinel-2 satellites: The European Space Agency's Sentinel-2 satellites, which revisit an area approximately every five days, are being used in India's burnt-area mapping exercises for internal assessments.
  • Limitations: Agricultural fires are generally smaller and less intense than forest fires. Harvesting, ploughing and field preparation can produce land-surface changes similar to burnt patches. Short intervals between harvesting and sowing, along with cloud cover and haze, further complicate detection.
  • Accuracy assessment: Satellite-derived burnt-area maps are regularly compared with higher-resolution imagery to verify their accuracy.

Measures Needed to Improve Monitoring

  • Ground-level verification: Following an inter-ministerial review in October, the Centre directed District Collectors to intensify ground patrols, particularly after 3 p.m., when conventional satellite observations are limited.
  • Integrated monitoring: Combine active-fire detection, burnt-area mapping and field-level inspections instead of relying exclusively on satellite fire counts.
  • Improved satellite capabilities: Incorporate data from satellites with different observation timings and higher-resolution sensors to detect small and short-duration fires.
  • Standardised measurement: Develop a common methodology for measuring the total agricultural area affected by stubble burning to improve the reliability of official estimates.
  • Better policy assessment: Use more accurate estimates of burnt areas and emissions to assess pollution levels and implement appropriate air-pollution control measures.

Relevant Concepts for UPSC

MODIS vs VIIRS

ParameterMODISVIIRS
Full formModerate Resolution Imaging SpectroradiometerVisible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite
Satellite associationAqua and TerraSuomi-NPP
Main applicationLand, ocean, atmosphere and fire monitoringEarth observation, including active-fire detection
ResolutionGenerally 1 km for active-fire detectionGenerally 375 m and 750 m products

PM2.5

  • Meaning: Fine particulate matter having an aerodynamic diameter of 2.5 micrometres or less.
  • Significance: Can penetrate deep into the lungs and enter the bloodstream, increasing the risk of respiratory and cardiovascular diseases.

Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP)

  • Meaning: Emergency framework for controlling air pollution in Delhi-NCR through progressively stricter measures according to air-quality levels.
  • Implementation: Coordinated by the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) in Delhi-NCR and adjoining areas.
  • Significance: Includes restrictions on construction activities, industrial operations and polluting vehicles at different stages of worsening air quality.

Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology (IITM)

  • Location: Pune, Maharashtra.
  • Administrative control: Ministry of Earth Sciences.
  • Role: Research in atmospheric sciences, monsoon dynamics, air pollution and weather-related phenomena. It also develops air-quality forecasting systems such as SAFAR.

Prelims Question

Q1. With reference to satellite-based monitoring of agricultural residue burning in India, consider the following statements:

  1. Active-fire detection and burnt-area mapping measure different aspects of fire activity, and therefore a decline in detected active fires does not necessarily indicate a proportionate decline in the area affected by burning.
  2. Burnt-area mapping can identify certain fires missed during satellite overpasses because the changes caused by burning may remain detectable even after the fire has extinguished.
  3. Cloud cover affects active-fire detection but does not significantly affect burnt-area mapping, since the latter relies exclusively on changes in land-surface temperature.
  4. A satellite with a higher spatial resolution can improve the detection of small agricultural fires, but it cannot by itself eliminate the limitations arising from observation frequency.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

(a) 1, 2 and 4 only
(b) 1 and 3 only
(c) 2, 3 and 4 only
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4

Answer: (a) 

Explanation:

  • Statement 1 is Correct: Active-fire detection counts fires observed at particular moments, whereas burnt-area mapping estimates the land surface affected by burning. Fewer detected fires may coexist with a relatively large burnt area.
  • Statement 2 is Correct: Burnt-area mapping uses changes in surface reflectance between pre-fire and post-fire images. Such changes may persist after the fire is extinguished.
  • Statement 3 is Incorrect: Cloud cover can obstruct optical satellite observations and affect burnt-area mapping as well. Burnt-area mapping is not based exclusively on land-surface temperature.
  • Statement 4 is Correct: Higher spatial resolution helps identify smaller fires, but frequent satellite observations are separately required to overcome temporal gaps.