AFTER SHENZHEN: HOW INDIA CAN FORGE A FOURTH POLE

22 Nov 2026

Tags: International Relations   Groupings   Global agreements

Source: The Hindu

Context: Following an unprecedented trilateral meeting of the U.S., China and Russia in Shenzhen on November 19, the article argues that these three powers increasingly view themselves as the principal decision-makers in the emerging world order. India should take the initiative to create a fourth pole comprising like-minded nations to promote a genuinely multipolar international system.

India's Position in the Emerging World Order

  • Multipolarity: India has traditionally advocated a multipolar world order, implicitly assuming that it would emerge as one of its major poles. However, great power status must be earned through economic and military strength rather than claimed on the basis of civilisational heritage.
  • India's limitations: Low per capita income, rising inequality and incomplete self-reliance in defence manufacturing constrain India's ability to emerge as an independent economic and military pole.
  • Alternative approach: India can use its diplomatic influence and leadership to create a collective fourth pole, rather than waiting to achieve conventional great power status.

Action Plan for Creating the Fourth Pole

  • Building a collective of nations: India should advocate a fourth pole comprising multiple countries rather than a single nation, united by strategic autonomy, respect for sovereignty, opposition to expansionism and participation in decision-making. Potential partners include Japan, Taiwan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Ukraine, Germany, Cameroon, the Philippines, Denmark and Brazil.
  • Diplomacy of conscience: India should take a firm stand against civilian casualties, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity. The article cites the 2024 ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh and ongoing civil wars in Sudan and Yemen as examples of conflicts requiring international attention.
  • Mediation and conflict resolution: India should position itself as a mediator and facilitator in international conflicts, including the Russia-Ukraine war, while placing civilian protection and humanitarian concerns at the centre of its mediation efforts.

Strengthening the Multilateral System

  • Rebuilding multilateral engagement: Groupings such as G20 and BRICS can build trust but cannot replace the legitimacy of established multilateral institutions, particularly the United Nations. India should strengthen its presence by hosting important UN and associated multilateral agencies.
  • Demonstrating diplomatic magnanimity: India is contesting against Tajikistan for an elected UN Security Council seat for 2028–29. The author suggests that India could withdraw in Tajikistan's favour, generating goodwill among Global South countries.
  • Supporting equitable representation: In the election of the next UN Secretary-General, India could support a Latin American candidate, considering the region's claim to the post through equitable regional representation.
  • Long-term diplomatic interests: India should prioritise building international goodwill and lasting partnerships over short-term institutional gains.

Upholding International Law

  • Countering transactionalism: The proposed fourth pole should reject purely transactional international relations and oppose the weakening of international law.
  • Commitment to international conventions: India should lead by signing and ratifying important international legal instruments, particularly the UN Convention Against Torture (UNCAT) and the 1951 Refugee Convention, demonstrating its commitment to human rights and refugee protection.

Strategic and Nuclear Security

  • Preventing nuclear oligarchy: India should oppose a world order in which the U.S., Russia and China monopolise strategic nuclear weapons and become the sole arbiters of international security.
  • Collective nuclear arrangements: Like-minded nuclear-armed countries within the proposed collective could develop common rules to regulate the expansion of strategic nuclear arsenals and potentially establish a joint nuclear umbrella for mutual security.
  • Strategic autonomy: Countries outside the Shenzhen grouping should collectively resist becoming subordinate to decisions taken by the three major powers.

Relevant Concepts for UPSC

  • Strategic Autonomy
    • Meaning: Ability of a country to independently make foreign policy and security decisions without being constrained by external powers.
    • India's approach: Maintaining independent relations with competing power centres while cooperating on issues of mutual interest.
  • Multipolar World Order
    • Meaning: International system in which power and decision-making are distributed among multiple influential countries or groupings rather than concentrated in one or two dominant powers.
    • Significance: Promotes greater representation, reduces hegemonic dominance and creates opportunities for middle and emerging powers.
  • Joint Nuclear Umbrella
    • Meaning: Security arrangement in which one or more nuclear-armed countries extend nuclear deterrence assurances to partner countries against external nuclear threats.
    • Example: NATO's nuclear-sharing and extended deterrence arrangements, particularly the U.S. nuclear umbrella over its allies.

Key International Conventions

ConventionSignificance
UN Convention Against Torture (1984)Prohibits torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
1951 Refugee ConventionDefines refugee status and establishes the principle of non-refoulement (no forced return to persecution).

Prelims Question

Q4. Consider the following pairs

International instrument / ArrangementPrincipal feature
1. UN Convention Against TortureProhibition of torture, including during emergencies
2. 1951 Refugee ConventionPrinciple of non-refoulement
3. NATO nuclear-sharing arrangementsComplete transfer of ownership of nuclear weapons to non-nuclear member states
4. UN Security Council elected membershipPermanent membership with veto power

How many of the above pairs are correctly matched?

(a) Only one
(b) Only two
(c) Only three
(d) All four

Answer: (b) 

Explanation:

  • Pair 1 is Correct: Article 2(2) of UNCAT prohibits invoking exceptional circumstances, including war or public emergency, as justification for torture.
  • Pair 2 is Correct: The 1951 Refugee Convention establishes non-refoulement under Article 33, prohibiting the return of refugees to territories where their life or freedom would be threatened, subject to specified exceptions.
  • Pair 3 is Incorrect: NATO nuclear sharing involves arrangements for deterrence and potential deployment. It does not transfer ownership of nuclear weapons to non-nuclear member states.
  • Pair 4 is Incorrect: Elected members of the UNSC serve two-year terms and do not enjoy veto power. The veto is available only to its five permanent members.