G3 CANNOT WRITE RULES, EVEN IF IT WANTS TO: CHANGING GLOBAL ORDER AND MULTILATERALISM

22 Nov 2026

Tags: International Relations   Groupings   Global agreements

Source: The Indian Express

Context: The proposed trilateral engagement among the US, China and Russia (G3) in Shenzhen, alongside the ASEAN, East Asia Summit and Quad meetings in Manila, highlights the growing shift towards great-power diplomacy, strategic autonomy and competing forms of multilateralism.

Manila Diplomacy: Rise of Strategic Autonomy and Multi-alignment

  • ASEAN's Strategic Autonomy: More than 20 heads of state and government participated in the 49th ASEAN Summit and related meetings, including the Quad and 21st East Asia Summit (EAS), demonstrating ASEAN's growing role as a neutral convening platform.
  • Balancing Major Powers: ASEAN engaged with China on economic cooperation and with the US on reciprocal trade, maritime security in the South China Sea and supply-chain resilience, without choosing sides.
  • Multi-alignment: Countries are engaging with competing powers simultaneously to maximise economic and strategic benefits while preserving decision-making autonomy.
  • Indo-Pacific Centrality: The region has emerged as a key centre of global security, critical supply chains and maritime stability.
  • APEC Engagement: The 33rd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Economic Leaders' Meeting brought together major economies, including the US, China, Russia, Japan, South Korea and Australia.

Shenzhen Trilateral: US–China–Russia (G3)

  • Nature: The proposed engagement among Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin reflects personalised great-power diplomacy and efforts to negotiate major geopolitical issues directly.
  • Limited Potential: Unlike the 1945 Yalta Conference, where major powers shaped post-war arrangements, the Shenzhen engagement is unlikely to produce a fundamental geopolitical reset because none of the three powers can achieve all its core objectives.
  • Ukraine Conflict: The US cannot resolve the war without Ukraine and the European Union being involved. Russia seeks favourable terms but cannot compel Ukraine to surrender.
  • US–China Rivalry: China's control over critical supply chains gives it leverage, but it cannot reverse US protectionist policies. Technological competition and strategic mistrust continue.
  • Nuclear Competition: China is reluctant to place its expanding nuclear arsenal under an arms-control treaty.
  • Russia's Strategic Interests: Putin seeks a favourable settlement on Ukraine and uses engagement with China and the US to reinforce Russia's global status.

Why Is the G3 Trilateral Significant?

  • Personalised Diplomacy: Direct negotiations among national leaders are increasingly replacing institutionalised diplomatic processes.
  • Great-power Bargaining: Major international issues risk being negotiated by a few powerful countries without adequate participation of affected nations.
  • Emerging Multipolarity: The engagement reflects the growing influence of multiple power centres, although it may also create a new hierarchy dominated by major powers.
  • Uncertain Outcomes: Despite their shared preference for transactional diplomacy, the three countries have different geopolitical objectives and competing visions of world order.

How Is the Trilateral Undermining Multilateralism?

  • Marginalisation of Institutions: Decisions taken through exclusive great-power negotiations may weaken the role of institutions such as the UN and WTO in collective decision-making.
  • Exclusion of Stakeholders: Discussing the Ukraine war without Ukraine and European powers risks legitimising decisions imposed by powerful countries on affected states.
  • Erosion of Common Norms: Unilateral tariffs, power politics and bilateral bargaining weaken rules-based international cooperation.
  • New Global Hierarchy: Multipolarity may not necessarily produce equality among nations; it could replace an older hierarchy with a new great-power hierarchy.
  • Rubber-stamping Risk: International institutions may increasingly be reduced to endorsing decisions already negotiated outside their formal mechanisms.

Changing Foreign Policy Approaches of the G3

  • China (Xi Jinping): Pursues a larger role in global governance through institutions and initiatives such as BRICS, AIIB, RCEP and the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), while challenging aspects of the Western-led international order.
  • Russia (Vladimir Putin): Advocates a multipolar world order and challenges the US-led system through military and diplomatic power. The annexation of Crimea (2014) and invasion of Ukraine (2022) demonstrate its rejection of established international norms.
  • USA (Donald Trump): Emphasises America First, bilateral deals, tariffs and transactional diplomacy, while expressing scepticism towards multilateral institutions such as the WTO and alliances such as NATO.

India's Strategic Autonomy and Multi-alignment

  • ASEAN Centrality: India supports ASEAN's central role in shaping the Indo-Pacific regional architecture.
  • Equitable Trade: Advocates fair and balanced international trade rules.
  • Quad Engagement: Reinforces maritime security and deterrence against unilateral actions and disruptive maritime behaviour.
  • Critical Minerals Cooperation: Promotes cooperation with ASEAN in critical minerals and supply-chain resilience.
  • Multi-forum Diplomacy: India's participation in ASEAN, EAS and Quad demonstrates its ability to engage with different power groupings without joining exclusive geopolitical blocs.

Important International Groupings for Prelims

GroupingNature / Significance
ASEANRegional organisation promoting Southeast Asian cooperation; emphasises ASEAN centrality.
East Asia Summit (EAS)Indo-Pacific leaders-led forum for strategic and political dialogue.
QuadStrategic grouping of India, US, Japan and Australia.
APECEconomic forum promoting trade and economic cooperation across the Asia-Pacific.
BRICSGrouping of major emerging economies promoting cooperation and reform of global governance.
AIIBAsian Infrastructure Investment Bank; China-initiated multilateral development bank.
RCEPRegional Comprehensive Economic Partnership, a major Asia-Pacific free trade agreement.

Way Forward: Towards Inclusive Multilateralism

  • Reform Global Institutions: Make institutions such as the UN, WTO and international financial institutions more representative of contemporary geopolitical and economic realities.
  • Inclusive Decision-making: Ensure affected countries participate in negotiations concerning their sovereignty, security and territorial integrity.
  • Strengthen Regional Institutions: Promote ASEAN centrality and regional cooperation to prevent excessive concentration of power among major countries.
  • Protect International Norms: Reinforce international law, peaceful dispute resolution and rules-based trade.
  • Greater Global South Representation: Emerging economies must have a meaningful role in shaping alternative global governance arrangements.

Prelims Question

Q1. Consider the following pairs relating to international institutions and economic groupings:

Grouping / InstitutionAssociated feature
1. AIIBMultilateral development bank headquartered in Beijing
2. RCEPTrade agreement involving ASEAN and five of its FTA partners
3. APECOperates on the basis of binding tariff-reduction commitments enforceable through a common dispute settlement mechanism
4. QuadCooperation among India, USA, Japan and Australia

How many of the above pairs are correctly matched?

(a) Only one
(b) Only two
(c) Only three
(d) All four

Answer: (c) 

Explanation:

  • Pair 1 is Correct: The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) is a multilateral development bank headquartered in Beijing, China.
  • Pair 2 is Correct: The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) involves the 10 ASEAN members and five FTA partners—China, Japan, South Korea, Australia and New Zealand.
  • Pair 3 is Incorrect: APEC is a non-binding economic cooperation forum. Its decisions are generally based on consensus and voluntary commitments, unlike formal free trade agreements.
  • Pair 4 is Correct: The Quad consists of India, USA, Japan and Australia.