WORKERS' PROTECTION AGAINST LAYOFFS IN INDIA

22 Nov 2026

Tags: Social Justice   Social Services   Human resources issues

Source: The Hindu

Context: Growing AI adoption and corporate investments in AI infrastructure have intensified concerns over job security. On the first anniversary of the implementation of the four Labour Codes (November 21), the debate focuses on severance pay, retrenchment protection and social security for workers losing employment.

Layoffs and Retrenchment in India

  • Terminology: Layoff is commonly used in the US; the corresponding Indian labour-law concept is retrenchment, though the two terms have distinct legal meanings.
  • Impact: Job loss affects workers across sectors, including coal mining, plantations, manufacturing, IT and government services, causing financial insecurity and psychological distress.
  • Blue-collar vs White-collar Workers: White-collar workers generally depend on specialised human capital and role-specific skills, while low-skilled and semi-skilled workers may migrate between employers until they secure their reservation wage (minimum wage at which they are willing to work).
  • Employment Contract: Protection depends significantly on the nature of employment, such as permanent, trainee or contractual employment.

Changes under the New Labour Codes

  • Rationalisation: The four Labour Codes consolidate multiple labour laws and adjudicating authorities, with objectives including ease of doing business, attracting foreign investment and addressing workers' concerns.
  • Industrial Relations Code, 2020: Replaced labour courts with Industrial Tribunals to consolidate industrial dispute adjudication.
  • Implementation Concerns: The effectiveness of tribunals depends on timely filling of vacancies, availability of qualified presiding officers and efficient dispute resolution.
  • Individual Retrenchment: Unlike some European systems, India's legal framework allows an individual worker's retrenchment to trigger the relevant legal protections and procedures.

Severance Pay and Its Taxation

  • Meaning: Severance pay is compensation provided by an employer to an employee upon termination of employment, intended to cushion the loss of income and associated benefits such as family health insurance.
  • Legal Position: Statutory retrenchment compensation is prescribed for eligible workers under specified labour laws, while additional severance payments may be provided as an employer practice or contractual benefit.
  • Tax Treatment: Severance compensation may be treated as 'profits in lieu of salary' and taxed accordingly. Certain amounts otherwise exempt may also become taxable under the head 'Income from Other Sources', subject to applicable provisions.
  • Concern: Taxation reduces the actual financial support available to retrenched workers during unemployment.

Limitations of India's Retrenchment Protection Framework

  • Sectoral Coverage: Traditional statutory retrenchment compensation provisions under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 were particularly relevant to eligible workers in industrial establishments, including factories, mines and plantations. Service-sector and IT workers, as well as informal workers, may not receive equivalent protection.
  • Weak Transition Support: Employers generally prefer one-time monetary compensation rather than providing counselling, legal assistance, retraining, testimonials and employment-exchange registration support.
  • Inadequate Social Security: Workers may lose employer-provided benefits, particularly health insurance, along with their regular income.

International Models of Unemployment Protection

CountryUnemployment Protection Mechanism
GermanyEarnings-linked unemployment insurance; benefits depend on previous earnings.
USAUnemployment insurance funded through payroll taxes, with federal-state administration and experience rating based on employers' unemployment claims.
UK and SingaporeDifferent unemployment and social protection arrangements that can offer models for adaptation.
  • Way Forward: India can examine international models and develop an unemployment protection system suited to its labour market, including insurance-based mechanisms.
  • Urban Employment: Urban unemployment schemes require different parameters from rural employment programmes due to differences in employment patterns and livelihood structures.

Existing Social Security Framework in India

  • Employees' State Insurance (ESI): Provides medical care and social security benefits to eligible insured workers and their families.
  • Implementation Gap: The availability of ESI hospitals remains disproportionately low compared to the beneficiary population, affecting access to healthcare.
  • Unemployment Assistance: The government can consider using tax revenues to provide unemployment assistance to vulnerable workers.
  • Family Support: The traditional joint-family system has historically acted as an informal safety net during unemployment, but cannot substitute for institutional social security.

Social Security for Gig, Platform and Informal Workers

  • Changing Employment Relations: The growth of gig and platform work is weakening the traditional employer-employee relationship, requiring alternative social security arrangements.
  • Labour Codes: The new framework recognises gig workers, platform workers and unorganised workers for social security purposes.
  • e-Shram Portal: Establishes a national database of unorganised workers to facilitate delivery of social security benefits.
  • Insurance-based Protection: Existing insurance mechanisms can be extended to gig workers to protect against income loss.
  • Shared Contribution Model: Gig workers could contribute a small premium towards income protection, potentially matched by aggregators and customers.
  • State Initiatives: State governments are also developing legislation to provide social security to gig and platform workers.

Way Forward

  • Universal Social Security: Bring formal, informal, gig and platform workers within an accessible social security framework.
  • Unemployment Insurance: Develop an earnings-linked or contribution-based unemployment protection mechanism suited to India's labour market.
  • Reskilling and Redeployment: Strengthen retraining, counselling and employment-placement support, particularly amid AI-driven job displacement.
  • Institutional Coordination: Improve coordination between government agencies, employers and citizens for effective social security delivery.
  • Role of Skills Development: Strengthen the Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship in labour-market governance to facilitate reskilling and employability.
  • Effective Implementation: Address the gap between India's existing institutional infrastructure and actual delivery of worker benefits.

Important Legal Provisions for Prelims

  • Industrial Relations Code, 2020: Consolidates laws relating to trade unions, conditions of employment in industrial establishments, and industrial disputes, including retrenchment.
  • Code on Social Security, 2020: Provides a framework for social security coverage, including provisions concerning unorganised, gig and platform workers.
  • e-Shram Portal (2021): Launched by the Ministry of Labour and Employment to create a national database of unorganised workers.